“Short-term” mission trips. It is a relatively new venture that works well for Western churches. There has been much argument over the past few decades as to the importance or impact of these trips.
Who benefits more? Those we go to serve or the groups going?
It can be helpful to ask long-term missionaries their views on incoming summer teams.
Is there presence helpful or hurtful? Do these strangers visiting a strange land require extra time, effort and resources for the locals, or do groups bring a much-need blessing?
Another demographic to ask similar questions are the local charitable organizations or churches.
I have been on, or lead, over thirty of these trips during my time in youth ministry. I do believe much good has come from these experiences. I certainly know the impact these trips have had on my students. Like our actual time-serving, some of the impact was very short-lived. However, over the years I have witnessed profound changes in hearts and lives and, perhaps most importantly, a genuine and lasting passion for missions in many people.
Sadly though, too often these trips become glamorize cultural experiences that have little long-term effect on either side of the equation.
A recent piece from The Onion (satire news source) highlights a very real and growing concern for short-term mission trips.
I am just as guilty of this as anyone…I will admit that. Following any of my trips, I am eager to post pictures and share stories that will last until the next adventure.
What we often fail to realize is that the people we intend to serve need much, much more than our presence and some photo op’s for two weeks.
Their lives, struggles and needs continue well past our “work vacation” and sometimes actually increase because of our time there.
I know of local organizations who actually lost money because of incoming groups.
I also know of groups raising close to $40,000 simply to travel some exotic country and virtually zero dollars remained in that country.
I have experienced both of these situations personally as well.
Knowing what the real needs and estimated costs to meet those needs would be, sometimes I shudder to think how much good could be given for the cost of one plane ticket.
But..we want the personal experience.
I have begun to ask this very honest question upon my travels:
What do you need the most? How can we support and serve you the most effectively?
Do you know what their honest answers are?
The truth is that every single place I have been and situation I have encountered, I have met amazing women and men who have inspiring vision, uncanny ability and ample time to really help their community. What they lack is perhaps the one thing that my group possesses in abundance. Money.
While I am still in favor on traveling to these places to visit people, hear their stories, encourage them and hopefully help in a practical way, I think it is essential that we bring more than just our smiles and “selfies”.
I recently asked on of my students to reflect and share his thoughts on past experiences and what he believes would be the best type of service trip.
Here is his response:
cool insights Dan, after our trip to Gabon, i begin to ask that myself…i agree that we also need to bring a cheque…i remember, when we were building the church foundation in the Village..the materials were not sufficient…and when i asked the guy there, if they could buy it , he said, “its not that easy because we dont have money”..im thinking.. 2 plane tickets cost 3,000 euros already and with that we could buy loads of materials with good quality…which means if two people were deducted on the trip , we will have 3000 euros more or less…im thinking the same idea for habitat for humanity…if instead we are sending 15 people ..we will send 10 people but the team will raise money for 15 people…imagine how much money we can bring to them.well, those are my thoughts…
Good post here. I have just come back from Jamaica doing my PHD research on STMs and I found a similar thing as to what you are talking about. Most Jamaican hosts need more resources or cash and the STM team bring this. But rarely do the hosts get a gift or resources after the team has left. Numerous PHD studies on STM show that trips DO NOT increase the money that STMers will give to their hosts, church or the organizations they went to but the people on the trips want the experiences of going to another country for themselves. However, we can’t only give money without some kind of relationship with the hosts. If there is no relationship and we just send money, we become a divorced angel investor and do know have a cross-cultural connection with the hosts.